That is why it is vital for ministers to clearly perceive the
Church's "reason for being." It is all too easy to lose the purpose in
the flurry of divers purposes. When the supreme task of the ministry is unidentified or
forgotten, many illegitimate forces can and will dictate to Church leaders. Rather than
guidance according to the will of Christ and by the Holy Spirit, the Church will be
directed by the self-centered motivations and fallible ingenuity of human ministers. The
result will be appealing effectiveness in the short-term, but in the long-term, tragic
ineffectiveness, because those ministered to do not reach their divine purpose.
What is the highest purpose of ministry? What is the goal of the
Church? What is the telos to which both are directed to find their fulfillment? In
Paul's letter to the Ephesians, we have statements essential to clarifying the goal of
ministry and the Church. In Eph. 4:11-16 the Church is given a "fish-eye" view
of the role of ministry in the grand mission of the Body of Christ.
In order to understand this passage, we must attempt to gain insight
into its context. In many cases, the setting for Paul's letters can be ascertained through
references and direct statements to concerns or problems in the church being addressed.
Then, by comparing this information with modern historical research on the era
contemporary with the epistle, a general composite of the reader's situation can be
sketched. The book of Ephesians is more difficult to treat in this manner, because it
lacks the specific statements usually found in other letters.
The continuing complex debate over either a Pauline authorship, or
composition by a disciple of Paul undercuts our efforts to determine the context of this
epistle. Added to this is the debate over whether the letter was originally written to the
Ephesians, and is compounded by the lack of geographic, historical, or social data. One is
left with examining the internal data of the epistle to gain understanding of its setting,
authorship, audience, and purpose. This absence of explicit information forces the reader
to use a rhetorical method and acknowledge the more general application of the epistle.
Assuming that the Paul of verse 1 is the Apostle Paul and that the manuscripts are
reliable that designate the audience as in Ephesus, we will make use of some rhetorical
analysis.
The readers of this book are assumed to be Christians by the writer.
They are referred to as: "saints" (1:1,15,18; 3:18; 5:3;6:18); believers
(1:1,13,15; 2:18; 3:12), those who "love our Lord Jesus Christ" (6:24). They are
"children of light" (5:8), a new creation in Christ Jesus (2:10). They have
received grace (1:6,8; 2:5,6), and the love of God (2:4) and Christ (5:2). They are
together in redemption (1:7), forgiveness (1:7; 4:32), salvation (1:13; 2:5,8), and
reconciliation (2:14-18). They are "sealed with the Spirit" (1:13; 4:30).
The readers are also Gentiles, as is indicated in several verses:
2:1-3; 11-13; 3:1; 4:17. This would explain why Paul takes the time to speak of the
"mystery of Christ" (3:4) revealed to him. This mystery, now made known, is the
fact that Gentiles are "sharers in the promise of Christ Jesus through the
gospel," (3:6 NRSV). The readers have also received Christian teaching (4:20-24). It
is assumed they know about Paul and his ministry (3:2; 3:13).
The writer enlightens us about the readers by his two prayers for
them. In 1:16-19 he tells them that he prays for their illumination. He desires for them
to grow and expand their faith and knowledge concerning the "hope of their
calling" (1:18) and the "immeasurable greatness of his power for us who
believe." (1:19) In 3:14-19 the writer prays for them to gain strength inwardly
through the Spirit, to be deeply grounded in love, and to comprehend in a greater measure
the love of Christ.
The structure of the letter may offer insight to the needs of the
readers. The book is divided into two parts: 1) 1:3-3:21, 2) 4:1-6:20. This division is
deduced by recognizing the distinct genre or oratory styles each one bears. While the
first section follows the genre of epideitic (artfully skilled and heightened rhetorical
expression of praise) language, the second is deliberative (persuasion to approve of or
follow certain public policy) in style.
The epideitic expression, in the first section, inspires the readers
to be in awe at the "heavenly" or glorious state of the "saints." The
deliberative, being paraenetic, reminds them of the deficiencies in their lives and
admonishes them to "lead a life worthy" of their "calling" (4:1). This
section also, warns them of the present spiritual battle with cosmic forces that they are
engaged in (6:10-17). This arrangement of the letter marks out the dialectic of the
Christian life universally: "saints" are in an exalted position with Christ, but
they have not yet fully grown-up in Christ.
In the first three chapters, the readers are made to recall how far
they have come in their faith and experience as saints. In the last three chapters, they
are made keenly aware of how much further they must go. The over-arching concern of Paul
emerges from this tension. He wants them to mature or reach the completion of their faith.
He does not want them to fall short of the goal of the Church. That is why he focuses
their attention on that goal at the very center of the letter. It is the goal of maturity
to the fullness of Christ. Let us look more closely at how Paul clarifies this.
Starting at verse 11 we read the completion of a thought begun in
verse 7. Christ has gifted each member of the Church with grace. Paul cites Ps. 68:18 to
theologically connect Jesus' ascension to His giving (give - twelve times; gift - four
times) the Spirit-gifts to the Church. The "gifts" that Christ gives to the
Church by the Spirit are persons: "apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and
teachers." While it may intrigue us to know just what the nature of each
gift-minister is, the writer does not make that known. He is more concerned with the
purpose of their ministry than their office or nature.
What is their purpose? Why are they given? "For the completing
of the saints for the work of ministry, for the building up of the body of Christ."
There has been disagreement over the relationship of the three phrases of verse 12. While
some translations place a comma between "saints" and "for" (KJV, Con),
and thereby disconnect their relatedness, most (NASB, NRSV, RSV, NIV, TEV, NKJV, et. al.)
connect 12a with 12b, expressing that the completing of the saints is to equip them to
perform the work of ministry.
The issue that ensues from this difference is: Did the writer intend
the gift-ministers to be seen as performing all three functions of verse 12? Or, do they
serve to complete the saints that they may perform the last two functions? For some, the
former is believed to lead to a hierarchy of ministry. The fact is, you could have a
hierarchy of sorts either way, because the saints are dependent upon the gift-ministers
listed. On the other hand, if the gift-ministers, as saints themselves, are viewed as
co-ministers with the saints, each would serve or minister to the other. Because this
section begins by reminding the readers they were all gifted with grace (v.7), and because
of the corporate inter-dependence of the members of the body for growth (v.16), the latter
seems more plausible.
The meaning of katartismos is rendered with various
connotations: "perfecting," (AV) "equipment of saints," (Houlden)
"completion," (Lincoln) "training" or "preparing," (Patzia)
"mending," (Robertson). No matter which is used, the notion is of bringing to a
capability to perform service and to build up (oikodoman) the body of Christ.
Because 'edification' is always used in connection to the corporate Body of Christ (A.T.
Robertson, The Body), the maturity and growth mentioned is not in reference to
individual growth alone. The gift-ministers' purpose is to help mature the saints that
they may help to build up the whole body.
This desired end is directed toward a grand culmination: "Until
we all attain the unity of faith, and the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a mature man,
unto the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ." The verb katantao
suggest a downhill movement and "signifies 'arriving at a certain place,'"
(Barth, p. 484). On nine occasions in Acts it refers to travelers arriving at their
destination (Foulkes, p. 121). The destiny of all saints is typified by a
"unity" of both "faith" and the "knowledge of the Son of
God."
Paul uses a metaphorical phrase which depicts the consummate Church
as a full-grown adult. As a single human organism the saints grow-up together to their
"full height" which is the "fullness (pleromatos: four times) of
Christ." This is the "certain place" to which the Church, as a body, is to
arrive. Not only is Christ the standard by which the Church measures its completeness, but
Christ is the goal toward which the Church is moving as it grows. Paul gives a sense of
Christ being completed through the completed, matured, and grown-up Church. The
"completeness" of the "body" becomes the "completeness" of
Christ.
They are not to remain immature or under-developed as
"infants" (nepioi). They should not be easily "tossed back and
forth" as on a wave of the sea (kludon; cp. Lk. 8:24), or "whirled
about" as a leaf in the wind by false teaching. To be tricked (kubeia -
playing with dice) by men who "in craftiness practice deception" is indicative
of immaturity in faith and knowledge of Jesus Christ. On the contrary, they are to
demonstrate the "truth in love." Though translations render this "speaking
the truth in love," the Greek gives no verb in this verse for speaking. The word aletheuo
means "truthing in love" or to deal truly or truthfully (Foulkes).
By the character of unity and authentic love for one another, each
member of the body will "grow-up in every way in Him, who is the Head, even
Christ." The expressions "Head" (kephala) and "body" are
figural for the relationship between the Christ and the Church. The meaning of
"Head" seems to include the idea of authority (1:22;23) as well as the source
(4:16). Verse 16 conveys the thought that Christ as Head directs and co-ordinates the
body. "From Whom the whole body, joined and united together by the means of every
ligament with which it is supplied ('every constituent joint' NEB), according to the
proper working of each individual part, makes the body grow up in building itself up in
love."
This verse is both fascinating and difficult. In Col. 2:19 this
verse is almost duplicated. It begins exactly the same (ek ou pan to soma). Both
use the word haphe (a 'touch' or 'point of contact'), which derives from harmos
(fastening in construction or shoulder-joint of the body). They both use sunbibazomenon
which is used for bringing people together, and conveys a sense of "functional
unity" (Foulkes). Another word used to express unity, sunarmologoumenon, is
found in 2:21 to denote how believers are "joined together" as a "temple in
the Lord."
These two "sun" words link to other "together"
words in Ephesians (2:5 suzoopoieo; 2:6 sunegeiro & sugkathizo;
2:22 sunoikodomeo) and to unity language (3:6 "fellow heirs,"
"members of the same body," & "sharers" ) to correlate the
importance of unity to maturity. Since they are united in salvation, faith, and promise,
their growth should be together. As Foulkes cogently states, "each member does not
seek its own growth, but that of the body as a whole, not its own edifying, but the
edifying of the whole."
Christ is declared the one who puts the body parts together,
creating their relationships ("connections" or "joints") by His
Spirit. These relationships are "built up" through love and the proper use of
each members gifts. The intent being the growth of the body to completeness in Christ. The
increase is not to be viewed as numerical but spiritual. Through their relationships of
service and love to one another, they grow in their faith and knowledge of Christ. As
their relationships with each other grow, so do their relationships with Christ. This
enables them to serve and love each other even more. This is Paul's prayer and highest
desire for them (3:14-19).
Of the many implications of this passage, several stand out. The
visible Church has often been faulted in history for its imperfections. Some of these
imperfections have been dreadful enough to cause one to doubt the visible Church is
connected to the invisible one. Nevertheless, we are reminded here that the Church is not
"complete" yet. This does not excuse immaturity or failure to honor Christ. What
it means is: the Church is on a journey. It lives in the tension between being
"exalted" spiritually and reaching experiential maturity. While we are Christ's
"body" we are not "grown-up" yet. That point will come in the
Consummation when both we and Christ are "fulfilled."
The second issue relates this passage to the modern Church Growth
movement (CGM). The primary question is well asked by Os Guinness: "Is the church of
Christ primarily guided and shaped by its own character and calling -- or by
considerations and circumstances alien to itself?" It would seem when looking at the
characteristics of the CGM that many considerations are alien.
One of deficiencies is a lack of theological depth. Paul tells us
that the ministers of the Word are "gifts" to establish and keep the Church in
truth and thereby complete her. The CGM looks more to modern sociological tools and
economic paradigms for the means to perfection. Paul exhorts us to acknowledge our Head,
Jesus Christ, as the goal toward which we mature. Yet the CGM by its techniques and
insights looks to achieve "success" that makes Christ seem less necessary. We
see the end in mind shapes the ideal or model of the Church.
By the "exaltation of numbers" the focus is on quantity in
the CGM. In contrast, Paul speaks in the language of quality. He talks of each one serving
the other in love so that unity and truth will lead them all to maturity. CGM looks at
masses, demographics, and statistics. Paul says serve each other, build relationships, and
grow up in Christ. In the CGM the profile of the minister is changed from servant,
minister of the Word, and builder of people, to an executive needing modern managerial
abilities.
Marketing becomes high in the CGM priorities. As one instructor has
stated: "The audience, not the message, is sovereign." In fact, the goal of the
CGM (which may be the goal of many churches outside of the CGM) may be the physical
inclusion of the greatest number of people within a church. Paul's declarations in
Ephesians seems strangely absent of this language. Paul sees a much different goal or
purpose for the Church: the up-building of God's people to the purpose of fulfilling
Christ. "Given that Jesus Christ is the head of the church and hence the origin and
goal of its growth, growth is only possible in obedience to its head." (Hans Kung)
Paul's instruction in Eph. 4:11-16 makes it plain that the goal of the ministry and the
Church is maturity through truth, love, and unity, that not only completes Christ's body,
but that completes or fulfills Christ Himself!